Welcome!

SOA & WOA Authors: Salvatore Genovese, Yeshim Deniz, Mark O'Neill, Irfan Khan, Vikas Aggarwal

Related Topics: Weblogic

Weblogic: Article

Paths to SOA

High Roads, Low Roads, and Roads Less Traveled

This is possible by defining a new process that allows for the business-level analysis to occur concurrently with service design and development. Also known as the meet-in-the-middle approach, the agile strategy is more complex than the previous two, simply because it needs to fulfill two opposing sets of requirements. The process steps shown in Figure 4 demonstrate an example of how an agile strategy can be used to reach the respective goals of the top-down and bottom-up approaches.

Step 1: Begin the top-down analysis, focusing first on key parts of the ontology and related business entities
The standard top-down analysis begins but with a narrower focus. The parts of the business models directly related to the business logic being automated receive immediate priority.

Step 2: When the top-down analysis has sufficiently progressed, perform service-oriented analysis
While Step 1 is still in progress, this step initiates a service-oriented analysis phase. Depending on the magnitude of analysis required to complete Step 1, it is advisable to give that step a good head start. The further along it progresses, the more service designs will benefit.

Once the top-down analysis has sufficiently progressed, model business services to best represent the business model with whatever analysis results are available. This is a key decision point in this process. It may require an educated judgment call in order to determine whether the on-going top-down analysis is sufficiently mature to proceed with the creation of business service models. This consideration must then be weighed against the importance and urgency of pending project requirements.

Step 3: Perform service-oriented design
The chosen service layers are defined and individual services are designed as part of a service-oriented design process.

Steps 4, 5, and 6: Develop, test, and deploy the services
Develop the services and submit them to the standard testing and deployment procedures.

Step 7: As the top-down analysis continues to progress, revisit business services
Perform periodic reviews of all business services to compare their design against the current state of the business models. Make a note of discrepancies and schedule those services most out of alignment for a redesign. This will typically require an extension to an existing service in order for it to better provide the full range of required capabilities. Once redesigned, a service will need to again undergo standard development, testing, and deployment steps.

In order to preserve the integrity of services produced by this approach, the concept of immutable service contracts needs to be strictly enforced. Once a contract is published, it cannot be altered. Unless revisions to services result in extensions that impose no restrictions on an existing contract (such as the addition of new operations to a WSDL definition), Step 7 of this process will likely result in the need to publish new contract versions and the requirement for a version management system.

Pros and Cons
This strategy takes the best of both worlds and combines it into an approach for realizing SOA that meets immediate requirements without jeopardizing the integrity of an organization's business model and the service-oriented qualities of the architecture.

While it fulfills both short- and long-term needs, the net result of employing this strategy is increased effort associated with the delivery of every service. The fact that services may need to be revisited, redesigned, redeveloped, and redeployed will add up proportionally to the amount of services subjected to this retasking step.

Additionally, this approach imposes maintenance tasks that are required to ensure that existing services are actually kept in alignment with revised business models. Even with a maintenance process in place, services still run the risk of misalignment with a constantly changing business model.

Conclusion
Choosing an appropriate delivery strategy is a critical part of SOA planning. Assessing these and other approaches will confront you with some important decisions. The choice of strategy will determine the extent to which your service-oriented modeling and design efforts can realize those aspects of SOA most relevant to your organizational priorities and goals. In other words, the path you take will ultimately determine your destination.

.  .  .
This article contains excerpts from Service-Oriented Architecture: Concepts, Technology, and Design by Thomas Erl (approximately 800 pages, hardcover, ISBN: 0131858580, Prentice Hall/Pearson PTR, Copyright 2005). For more information, see www.serviceoriented.ws.

More Stories By Thomas Erl

Thomas Erl is the world’s top-selling SOA author and Series Editor of the Prentice Hall Service-Oriented Computing Series from Thomas Erl (www.soabooks.com). With over 100,000 copies in print worldwide, his books have become international bestsellers and have been formally endorsed by senior members of major software organizations, such as IBM, Microsoft, Oracle, BEA, Sun, Intel, SAP, CISCO, and HP. His most recent titles - SOA Design Patterns and Web Service Contract Design and Versioning for SOA - were co-authored with a series of industry experts and follow his first three books Service-Oriented Architecture: A Field Guide to Integrating XML and Web Services, Service-Oriented Architecture: Concepts, Technology, and Design, and SOA Principles of Service Design. Thomas is currently working with over 20 authors on a number of upcoming titles, including SOA Governance, SOA with .NET, SOA with Java, ESB Architecture for SOA, and SOA with REST. He is also overseeing the SOAPatterns.org initiative, a community site dedicated to the on-going development of SOA patterns. Thomas is the founder of SOA Systems Inc. (www.soasystems.com), a company specializing in vendor-neutral SOA consulting and training services. He is also the founder of the internationally recognized SOA Certified Professional program (www.soacp.com and www.soaschool.com). Thomas is a speaker and instructor for private and public events and is regularly invited to Gartner summits. He has delivered many workshops and keynote speeches, and is on the program committee for the International SOA Symposium. Articles and interviews by Thomas have been published in numerous publications, including SOA World Magazine, The Wall Street Journal and CIO Magazine. For more information, visit www.thomaserl.com.

Comments (0)

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.